0 INTRODUCTION
Playing in a fast midnight team game at the Pan American
Championships
in Corpus Christi in 1992, I heard my right-hand opponent open
1C. My
left-hand opponent alerted it and tried to explain, but there was
a
language problem and I didn't really understand. I assumed it was
a "Big
Club" of some sort, and bid 2C on a fair 5-card suit. This
was doubled
(8 or more points). Partner passed. So did opener. The contract
was not
a success. That was my introduction to Bogota Club. (We won the
match
anyway.)
An Unassuming Club ("AUC") is a bridge bidding
system based on a 1C opening
that is forcing but not necessarily strong; usually natural; and
that
allows experienced bridge players to use most of their present
methods.
Other one-level suit bids are limited to at most 18 high-card
points and
are natural. Whenever there has been a choice between natural
bidding and
artificial bidding, I have made an effort to keep it natural.
Other key
features include a 12-14-point 1NT and a natural and limited 2C
bid. The
system after 1D, 1H, 1S, and 1NT openings can be pretty much
whatever you
are used to (with a few exceptions). Only the bidding after 1C
(and to an
extent 2C) is peculiar to the system. It is a member of a family
of systems
called "intermediate clubs" that includes Vienna
System, Roman Club, Polish
Club, New South Wales Club, Bogota Club, and Power System. These
systems
have been popular in several parts of the world for decades but
have never
caught on in the United States.
0.0 Why?
Standard systems have a strong, forcing 2C opening. To use it
you need
nearly game-forcing values. It helps to have a long suit as well.
Many
experts open hands like SAQ98 HKQT5 D8 CAKQ4 1C, even though game
is
likely opposite very weak but fitting hands like SJ3 HJ7632 D7532
C65.
Even relatively strong balanced hands are typically opened in
three-card
minor suits, which responder is free to pass even without
support. Big Club
systems, where nearly all hands with as many as 16 or 17 points
are opened
1C and weaker hands with clubs must be opened something else,
solve those
problems at the expense of some others. Typically these systems
feature 2C,
2D, and 1D openings that are difficult to handle and the 1C
opening itself
is vulnerable to interference. An Unassuming Club solves all of
these
problems at the expense only of a rather complicated 1C opening.
I believe
it's the logical next step in scientific bidding. The key is
conservation
and wise use of bidding space.
0.1 How?
I will start with short description of each of the opening
bids and try to
give the flavor of the bidding that follows it. This is a short
summary
of the system, so after that the text stops. Later chapters will
consist
mostly of charts of meanings of bids.
0.1.0 The 1C Opening
With any hand with 19 or more points, or 18 points balanced,
open 1C. (So
far this sounds like an awfully conservative Big Club system.)
With a club
one-suiter in the range 16-18 points, open 1C. With a balanced
hand in the
range 15-17 high-card points with less than four diamonds (but
without
a five-card major), open 1C. With a three-suited hand short in
diamonds
(4-4-1-4 distribution, in the order spades, hearts, diamonds,
clubs) in
the range of a minimum opening bid up (about 11 high-card points
with this
distribution), open 1C. With five or more clubs and a four-card
major suit,
open 1C. That's five hand descriptions, ranging from a minimum
opening bid
to the strongest hand you might hold. The minimum openers all
have clubs.
The strongest hands may even be void in clubs. In between, the
balanced
15-18-point hands all have at least two clubs, and of course the
club
one-suiters all have at least six. That is, the weaker the hand,
the more
clubs it must have. The minimum hands all have real club suits.
That will
be important in some competitive auctions.
Responder bids 1D with any 0-5 points (occasionally a bad 6)
or with
6-9 points without a 4-card major. This is the first instance of
a "Herbert
negative." There will be others. A Herbert negative is
simply the cheapest
bid showing the worst hand. Most "negative" responses
and rebids in this
system will be the cheapest bid, although there will be
exceptions. I'm
not sure all of the exceptions are necessary, but they are
designed to
make bidding in An Unassuming Club (abbreviated AUC hereafter)
more like
standard bidding. Over the 1D response bidding will often be
artificial
and will usually be quite different from standard bidding. (The
1S and 1NT
rebids are natural, and the 2C rebid shows clubs and hearts. Not
everything
is artificial in this auction.)
Responding to a 1C opening with 5-8 high-card points and a
good
six-card major suit (that is, the equivalent of a good 6-9
points), bid the
suit at the two-level. Opener will treat this as a weak two-bid
and use
your regular methods of responding to a weak two.
With a good six or more points and a major suit of four cards
or
longer (but add a point for a five-card suit to two honors),
respond one of
the major suit. Do this even with a worthless four-card suit;
with a longer
minor; and with any strength from six good points up. That is,
any response
other than 1H, 1S, 2H, or 2S denies a four-card or longer major
suit. This
is not standard bidding but seems to work best in this system.
Bidding over
these responses is much like standard bidding.
With a surprising 10-15 HCP, a balanced hand, and no four-card
major
suit (or 5-card minor suit toward the top of the range), respond
1NT. This
response is forcing but not necessarily to game. Opener bids a
relatively
natural 2C with 11-14 points and responder will bid again only
with 12
or more points. This is another Herbert negative. All of opener's
other
rebids are forcing to game. 2D is artificial and not particularly
directed.
2H, 2S, 3C, and 3D show the 19-plus-point hands. 3NT is to play.
2NT is
stronger than 3NT. 3H and 3S show shortness.
All balanced hands with no four-card major or five-card minor
and 16
or more points respond 2NT. Continuations are like after 1NT only
a level
higher.
Minor suit responses are 2C and 2D. They show ten or more
points.
If in the 10-12-point range, the hand will be unbalanced or will
have a
concentration of strength in the suit bid. 2D guarantees at least
five
diamonds, but 2C may be bid on a very good four. Occasionally
responder may
bid 3C with the right preemptive hand, but should bear in mind
that opener
may have a strong notrump with as few as two clubs. Over 2C and
2D opener
again makes the cheapest bid with 11-14 points.
0.1.1 The 2C Opening
Opener bids 2C with about 10-15 high-card points, six or more
clubs, and no
four-card major suit. A 10-point hand will have good playing
strength and
decent defensive prospects; a 15-point hand will be rather the
opposite.
Responder's 2D and 2H are transfers to hearts and spades,
respectively;
2NT is natural, and 2S is an artificial inquiry. There are other
possible
response structures but this one seems to work well.
0.1.2 The 1D Opening
The 1D opening guarantees at least four diamonds and about
13-18 points.
These "points" need not all be in high cards. When
describing the bid to
opponents I usually say 11-18 points, since quite a few hands
with only
11 high-card points qualify. The bid is limited from below by the
weak 2D
bid and by the 12-14 1NT opening, so it will always be relatively
sound.
That is, if it's a diamond one-suiter it will be unsuitable for
2D (usually
because it's too strong) and if balanced it will be 15-17 points.
The only
really strange feature is that all hands in the 13-18-point range
with four
diamonds and five clubs (and not suitable for 1NT) are opened 1D.
This
can lead to some ambiguity on occasion but usually doesn't
matter. Also
possible is five diamonds and six clubs, but of course this is
very rare.
With 6 clubs and 4 diamonds, open 1C or 2C, depending on
strength.
Responses are almost exactly what they would be in a standard system.
There are several specialized rebids. For the most part they
allow
better definition of opener's hand than in standard systems,
taking
advantage of the head start offered by the limited opening bid.
0.1.3 The Major-Suit Openings
Opener shows at least five of the suit bid and about 12-18
points, not all
of which need be in high cards. Unlike the 1D opening, 5332
distribution
and 12-14 points is possible, since in AUC we don't usually open
1NT with
a five-card major suit. As with the 1D opening, however, it is
possible to
have five of the major and six clubs, although again it's rare.
0.1.4 The 1NT Opening
So you like a 15-17-point 1NT opening? Sorry. It doesn't work
well with
this system. Polish Club, a very closely related family of
systems,
generally uses a range of a good 15 to any 18 points. In such a
system,
after a 1C opening, you will need to use a more Polish-style
setup for the
1H and 1S rebids. 14-16 is quite playable in this family of
systems; as is
10-12 or 11-13. (I'm not fond of 4-point ranges, but you may be.)
But I
strongly suggest giving 12-14 a chance. It sets the opponents
some problems
that a stronger notrump opening doesn't. AUC has been designed
around it.
0.2 Organization of the Remainder of the Materials
Following the classic pamphlet "Kaplan-Sheinwold
Updated," by the late
Edgar Kaplan, I am arranging the remainder of the materials as a
chart of
bids divided into several "sub-systems," each
inaugurated by a different
opening bid, each with separate rules for which bids are strong
or weak,
forcing or nonforcing, artificial or natural. These are (1) the
1C opening,
(2) interference over 1C, (3) the 1NT opening, (4) the 2C
opening, (5) the
1D opening, and (6) other opening bids.
0.3 Abbreviations
The following abbreviations will be used throughout (if only occasionally):
"M" "either major suit" or "the first
major suit bid" m"
""either minor suit" or "the first minor suit
bid" OM" the
"other major suit om" the other minor suit any"
any strain
0.4 Evaluation Tools
Controls are counted two for an Ace and one for a King with
singleton Kings
not counted. Losers are a little more complicated. There are no
more than
three losers in a suit and A, K, or Q is not a loser in a suit of
at least
1, 2, or 3 cards, respectively. HCP means "high-card
points", counted in
the usual way. Points are a little more ambiguous. Use your
judgment.
Support points are HCP plus one for a doubleton, three for a
singleton, and
four or five for a void, with four-card or better trump support.
Subtract
a point if you have only three-card support. Be ready to adjust
support
points according to your judgment.
1 THE 1C OPENING
1C can be any of five hands:
1. 19 or more points, any distribution; or a balanced 18. The
points
need not all be in high cards, but if some are in distribution,
the
hand should have no more than five losers and at least five
controls,
and almost always at least 17 HCP. An 18-point 6322 should have
good
controls and a good suit.
2. 16-18 points with a club one-suiter. Again, not all need be
in high
cards, but 15 HCP in an ordinary 6322 hand should probably be
opened
2C.
3. 15-17 HCP balanced with less than four diamonds. (With four
or five
diamonds, open 1D.) Excellent controls and concentrated values
suggest
upgrading a 14 HCP hand; unsupported minor honors suggest
downgrading
an 18 HCP hand.
4. Specifically 4-4-1-4 distribution (that is, short in
diamonds) and
about 11-18 HCP.
5. Five or more clubs and at least one four-card major, and
about
11-18 points. 5440 hands with five clubs should be opened 1C.
1.0 Responses
Pass: Not allowed. The AUC 1C is forcing. Passing this bid
could have
severe consequences, as detailed in David Silver's book Tales Out
of
School. HThe author, at the gates of heaven: "I had no idea
what I was
doing there. The last thing I remembered was trying to explain to
Bruce
Gowdy why a two clubs opening bid was not always absolutely
forcing ..."
1D: 0-5 points (or possibly a bad 6) with a four-card major or
0-9 points
without one. With 6-9 points and a 4-card or longer major suit,
bid the
suit. This also means that by first bidding 1D and then showing
6-9 points,
responder denies a four-card major. This is important.
1M: A decent 6 points or more with four or more cards in the
suit bid.
With two major suits: bid the longer with unequal length; hearts
with 4-4;
or spades with 5-5 or 6-6. Bid a major suit in preference to an
equal or
longer minor.
1NT: 10-15 HCP, no four-card major, no five-card minor or good
4-card club
suit when toward a maximum.
2C: 10 or more points, no four-card or longer major, four good
clubs
(notrump will always be an alternative) or any five clubs, but
with 10-12
points and 5332 distribution consider bidding 1NT.
2D: 10 or more points, no four-card or longer major, five or
more diamonds,
if 5332 then either concentrated diamond honors or better than
minimum
values.
2M: 5-8 HCP and a good 6-card suit. By a passed hand, a bad 6-card suit.
2NT: 16 or more HCP, no four-card major, no five-card minor or
good 4-card
club suit.
3C: About 3-6 HCP, usually six clubs. It is a weakness of the
system that
we can't bid 3C preemptively more often, but we hope to recoup
that loss in
other places. Don't be too anxious to make this response, since
opener may
have a strong hand short in clubs.
1.1 Bidding Over the Negative
1C 1D ?
Responder has 0-5 points (maybe a bad 6) with any
distribution, or 6-9
without a 4-card or longer major. Unless opener has 16 points or
so, game
is unlikely; if responder has the lower range, opener needs to
have over
19 points or have really exciting distribution. In this age of
gossamer
overcalls, especially over nebulous openings, getting to this
point without
the opponents bidding makes it very likely that opener has the
19+-point
hand. That explains having quite a few strong rebids, including
the
cheapest bid at this point. Opener's rebids:
1H: Almost any hand of 19 or more points, or 18 balanced; but
not an
unbalanced one-suiter unless game-forcing values, and not a minor
two-suiter. That is, any "strong club" that doesn't
qualify for 2D or 2M or
2NT. (This rebid handles most of hand type 1.)
1S: 5+ clubs, 4 spades or 4-4-1-4, any strength within 11-18.
This is half
of hand type 5.
1NT: 15-17 points balanced; that is, hand type 3.
2C: 5+ clubs and 4 hearts, 11-18 points. Denies 4 spades. The
other half of
hand type 5.
2D: 27-28 HCP balanced; or a minor one-suiter not quite worth
a game force;
or a very strong minor two-suiter. Forcing.
2M: A good 6-card suit in a hand not quite worth a game force,
without a
side 4- card major or strong 4-card minor. Not forcing but seldom
passed.
Responder's bid of the next step is a second negative,
showing very bad hand. The single raise is stronger than
the double raise, and is forcing. To make a nonforcing
raise go through the Herbert second negative. Over
the Herbert negative, with a better than minimum hand
(4 losers) opener should bid a side concentration of
strength. Thus, 1C-1D; 2H-2S; 3C shows a concentration of
strength in clubs, perhaps KQx. Responder with something
useful should avoid rebidding 3M, which opener will almost
always pass. Responder may pass 3C in this auction.
2NT: 21-22 points balanced. Stayman and transfers are on.
3C: Club one-suiter too strong to be opened 2C but not worth
19 points;
about 16- 18 points (not necessarily all in high cards).
Responder's
bids are constructive, presumably stoppers for notrump. With a
weak hand
responder can pass.
3D: Roman Key-Card Blackwood (RKCB) in diamonds. The four Aces
and the King
of diamonds are keycards. The first step shows one or four; the
second none
or three; the third two without the diamond Queen; and the fourth
two with
the diamond Queen. Opener bids the next step (omitting 3NT and
diamonds)
to ask for the Queen of diamonds, Kings, then Queens. (Those
familiar with
Spiral Scan may substitute that here.) Note the inversion of the
usual
first two steps, for consistency with other instances of RKCB.
3M: RKCB in the named suit, as above.
4C: RKCB in clubs, as above.
3NT: Asks for specific Aces. 4C denies one; 5C shows the club
Ace; and 4NT
shows two Aces. 5C over 4NT asks which two; responder bids in the
order
Color (two Aces of the same color) RAnk (two major or two minor
Aces) or
SHape (two Aces of the same "shape," spades/diamonds or
hearts/clubs). The
mnemonic is "CRASH." Over any of these bids, the next
step similarly asks
for specific Kings. This is all very neat, but if you use it
twice you're
probably abusing it.
1.1.0 The Strong 1H Rebid
1C 1D 1H ?
Opener has 18+ points balanced or 19+ points with almost any
distribution;
but not an invitational 1-suiter or a minor 2-suiter, and certain
balanced
ranges are excluded. In essence, this suggestion of Henry Sun is
borrowed
from big-club relay systems such as Relay Precision and Moscito.
1S: Herbert second negative; 0-5 points (or a bad 6), any
distribution.
Now opener rebids 1NT with 18-20 balanced, 2C with a game force,
2D with
a flexible hand looking for a major-suit fit, and 2M with 5 or
more of a
major in a hand unsuitable for a 2M bid on the previous round.
Opener's
2NT rebid now is 23-24 points, and 3NT is an unlikely 29-30 (see
balanced
ladder below).
1NT: Precisely three kings and no other feature (Magi
Convention). No
4-card major because no 1M response to 1C.
2C: 6-9 points, but not three kings. As with Magi, no 4-card major.
2D, 2H, 2S: 0-4 HCP with a six-card (occasionally 7) suit.
3-level bids: 0-4 HCP with a seven-card suit, or possibly 6 clubs.
The responses from 2D up are treated as if they were opening
preempts. New
suits are forcing and 2NT asks for a feature in a non-minimum
hand.
Over 1S opener bids 1NT with 18-20 points balanced; 2C with
game-forcing
values including 25-26 and 31-32 balanced; 2D asking responder to
bid a
4-card major or a 5-card minor; 2M with a flexible hand with 5 or
more of
the major.
Assuming responder always shows a weak hand by bidding the
next step
(represented by a dot), this is the "ladder" of bidding
sequences showing
balanced hands:
1NT 12-14 C.1NT 15-17 C.1H.1NT 18-20 C.2NT 21-22 C.1H.2NT
23-24 C.1H.2C.2NT
125-26 C.2D.3NT 27-28 C.1H.3NT 29-30 C.1H.2C.3NT 31-32
Notice all sequences ending in 1NT are weaker than any
sequence ending in
2NT; and the ones ending in 2NT are weaker than those ending in
3NT. The
two intermediate bids are usually 1H and 2C, and the longer the
auction
the stronger the hand. Because 1C.3NT is the specific ace ask,
1C.2D.3NT
substitutes for it. With those rules in mind you will usually be
able to
work out the chart in your head, at the table, which is good,
because it
would be very difficult to remember otherwise.
After 1C-1D; 1H-1NT or 1C-1D; 1H-2C, obviously opener can't
rebid 1NT.
Equally obviously, opener needn't bid 2D asking for a 4-card
major because
responder can't have one. In either case 2D shows the missing
balanced
range, 18-20. All other bidding is natural.
[DJG - Nowadays we use 1C-1D; 1H-2C; 3NT to show 18-20
balanced, since
99% of the time that's where we're ending up anyway. 2D then
becomes
natural. That would probably apply over 1C-1D; 1H-1NT if that
ever
arose, which it never does.]
Finally, note that all 3 ways of getting to 1NT are in a sense
unsound,
although protected somewhat by the Law of Total Tricks. If an
opponent
opens an unassuming 1C and you have a hand that would double a
strong
notrump opening, just pass. You may get a chance to double it on
the next
round, or even the round after that.
In all of these sequences, the cheapest club bid is Stayman
and the
cheapest red-suit bids are transfers. (After the 15-17 1NT rebid
that may
not seem to make much sense, but at least it gets back with the
field,
and it's simple.) An alternative over the 15-17 1NT rebid, which
David
Goldfarb suggested, is the regular transfer scheme but 2C as a
puppet
to 2D. Responder then bids 2H with four cards in each major, or
perhaps
4-3. In this scheme, the jump to 3m is weak and 3m through the
puppet is
invitational. The meanings of 2S and 2NT after the puppet are up
to you.
1C-1D; 1H-1S; 2C is a game force. Responder bids a third
negative 2D with
no Ace, no King, and less than 2 Queens. Otherwise responder's
bids are
natural (although 2NT may be bid with no good suit) and show at
least A, K,
or QQ. Bidding proceeds naturally.
After 1C-1D; 1H-1S; 2D, responder is required to bid a 4-card
or longer
major if one is held; or a decent 5-card minor (avoid bidding 3D
with a
bad suit, in particular); otherwise 2NT. In principle opener has
less than
game-forcing values, but may use this sequence with a stronger
hand knowing
what to do over each response.
1C-1D; 1H-1S; 2M can be passed. It usually shows a 5-card suit
and is
always limited. Both partners know game is unlikely and all bids
that don't
show a fit suggest a final contract. Optionally, a Herbert
negative may be
used in this sequence just as in 1C-1D; 2M. Opener's rebid will
often be a
second suit, though, and doesn't promise extra values.
1.1.1 Minors In Principle
1C 1D 2D ?
Opener may have 27-28 HCP balanced; or a minor one-suiter not
quite worth a
game force; or any strong minor two-suiter. 2D is forcing. It's
also pretty
rare. Responder has three possible rebids:
2H: 0-5 HCP, any distribution.
2S: 6-9 HCP, as usual no four-card major, but not three Kings.
2NT: Our friends the Magi; three Kings.
Over any of these, opener rebids 3NT with 27-28 points
balanced; 2NT with
most minor two-suiters; 2S (forcing) with a minor two-suiter and
a spade
fragment; and 3m with a limited minor one-suiter. Higher
major-suit bids
are fragments in minor two-suiters. This is how you bid an
"Acol 2" in a
minor suit.
1.1.2 Acol Twos In The Majors
1C 1D 2M ?
Well, not exactly Acol Twos. The Acol system was invented in
the 1930's and
40's by several players at the Acol Bridge Club on Acol Street in
London.
The 2D, 2H, and 2S opening bids in Acol are forcing for one round
and
show a good suit in a good hand, but not usually good enough to
force to
game. The natural forcing opening allows convenient bidding of
very strong
two-suiters without fear of interference, among other things. If
we open
these hands 1C, interference can be quite a problem. For that
reason, in
AUC we limit the bids to one-suiters, or 6-4 at most, and because
there is
never a substantial second suit, the 2M rebids need not be
forcing. (We
open most strong two-suiters in a suit other than clubs. When we
open one
of them 1C, we usually rebid 1H or 2D.)
To rebid 2M, opener should have five or more controls and four
or five
losers; and usually at least 17 HCP. Because opener will rebid 2C
in the
auction 1C-1M, forcing to game, it is dangerous to open 1C on
weaker hands
planning to rebid 2M. If partner has a misfitting 6 HCP there
will seldom
be a makable game. Responder's rebids:
Pass: A hand very unlikely to take a trick.
Next step: That is, 2S over 2H and 2NT over 2S. Herbert
negative. Either
a hand with a fit and some possibility of taking a trick or a
substantial
misfit that may be a little stronger. With the values for an
invitational
single raise, bid a Herbert negative and pass if opener is unable
to muster
more than 3M. Therefore, over the negative, with better than a
minimum,
opener bids a side concentration of strength. It's indirect, but
it works.
New suit: Some values and a decent suit, usually without
substantial
support. Not forcing but opener will usually bid again.
4M: Distributional raise. Opener will pass.
3M: Forcing. Almost always 3-card support since it's difficult
for
responder to have a hand worth suggesting slam with less than 6
points.
2NT/2H: Scattered values, suggesting a notrump game.
1.1.3 The Intermediate Club One-Suiter
1C 1D 3C ?
Opener has a hand worth a sound jump to 3C over a 1-level
response. This
will usually be 16-18 HCP, although a good suit and good controls
may make
a 15-point hand worth upgrading, or an even weaker hand with
exciting
distribution and controls. Opener may have a side four-card
diamond suit
but not a four-card major.
Responder's bids other than raises and game bids are forcing.
Three-level bids will usually be stoppers for notrump. 3C is
presumably
playable so responder can pass with almost any bad hand.
1.1.4 Spades And Clubs
After 1C-1D, opener's 1S rebid shows (surprise!) spades and
natural clubs.
It may be 4 spades and 5+ clubs or 4-4-1-4. Bidding is natural.
Responder
should assume opener has bid clubs and spades in a natural
system. Of
course, responder can't be particularly strong, so opener is free
to pass
if it seems a reasonable contract has been reached.
1.1.5 Hearts And Clubs
After 1C-1D, opener's 2C rebid shows 5+ clubs and 4 hearts.
Responder's new
suits are constructive but again opener may pass with a minimum.
1.1.6 The RKC Rebids: 3D, 3H, 3S, and 4C
Responder bids in steps. I assume for this discussion that you
play "1430"
RKC; that is, the first step shows 1 or 4 keycards, and the
second 0 or
3. (I believe that has a definite advantage when the RKC bid is
4NT and
the agreed suit is hearts. It probably doesn't matter much in
most other
situations, and can be a real pain in a minor suit.) I trust you
to be able
to work out the responses if you use the first step for 0 or 3.
Keycards are the four Aces and the King of the
"agreed" suit. In these
auctions, the "agreed" suit is the one bid. A
"step" is a possible bid;
for instance, over 3D, 3H is the first step and 3NT is the third.
With 1
or 4 keycards, bid the first step. With 0 or 3, bid the second
step. With
two keycards but without the Queen of trumps, bid the third step.
With two
and the Queen, bid the fourth step, which is always the step
below the
suit of the ask. (One level of bidding is five steps.) 3NT, bids
in the
"agreed" suit, 6NT, and any bid at the seven-level are
to play. Opener may
bid the first step over the response, skipping any "to
play" bid, to ask
for the trump Queen or Kings, depending on whether the Queen has
already
been shown. Asking for Kings guarantees all keycards and either
holding the
Queen or enough length that it doesn't matter. After Kings, the
next step
asks for Queens. Naturally you don't count the trump King or
Queen in the
response.
I believe there are better response systems; see for instance
Spiral
Scan, in George Rosenkranz's ROMEX books. This is not the place
for an
explanation.
1.2 Bidding Over a Major-Suit Response
1C 1M ?
Responder has shown at least six points, not necessarily all
in high cards,
and at least four cards in the suit bid. This is sufficiently
similar to
standard bidding that our auctions will seem a lot more familiar
than they
did in the previous section. The auctions that are the same after
either
response are given first.
1NT: 15-16 HCP balanced. Opener denies 4-card support and over
1H will have
4 spades only when 4-3-3-3. (Feel free to change that if it's not
your
style.) This range may seem intuitively to be too narrow, but it
gives us
the freedom to pass 1NT where other players will be worried about
missing
game.
2NT: 17-18 HCP balanced, as above. Remember, responder has a good 6+ pts.
2C: 19 or more points; usually hand type 1 from the list, but
may be a
hand upgraded to 19 or more points because of a fit with partner.
This is
opener's only strong rebid. It is forcing to game.
2M: The single raise may be three- or four-card support. The
spade raise
will be three cards slightly more often than the heart raise.
Even with
three-card support the raise may be based on a balanced hand,
since it's
wise to avoid rebidding notrump with a small doubleton in an
unbid suit.
The range is about 13-16 support points.
3C: About 16-18 points with a good 6-card club suit. In a
pinch, a mediocre
6-card club suit.
3D: RKC in diamonds, as in the previous section.
3OM: RKC in OM.
3NT: Asks specific aces, as in the previous section.
4C: RKC in clubs.
4M: A raise worth about 19 support points but with no
singleton, and not
well suited to slam. The alternative is to bid 2C and then 2M or
3M as
required. That would show a stronger hand. This rebid is usually
a balanced
18- point hand that has been upgraded. Splinter raises go through
2C.
1C 1H ?
1S: Four spades, no more than 18 points, and at least four
clubs. With
4S4C32 distribution, four cards in each black suit, I recommend
rebidding
1S. This denies four hearts. I recommend rebidding 1S with
4-3-2-4 and
4-3-1-5 distribution, so it does not deny three hearts. (You may
choose to
ignore either or both of these recommendations without doing
violence to
the system.)
2D: 6 or more clubs, 3 hearts, in a hand worth a 3C rebid
("Bridge World
Death Hand"). This allows for a final contract of 2H, 2NT,
or 3C, while
leaving room for other constructive bids. Standard bidders are
stuck with
3C, when a heart or notrump contract may be better. (Slightly
non-standard
bidders will happily reverse into a fragment with this hand. Our
reverse is
nonforcing, so that isn't such a happy solution here.) Forcing.
2S: An unbalanced four-card raise of hearts, worth about 17-18
support
points. Responder will usually relay with 2NT, and now opener's
rebids are
3C with five or more clubs and short spades, 3D with 4-4-1-4, and
3H with
five or more clubs and short diamonds. (The middle step is the
odd one;
otherwise bid the suit of the same color as the shortness.)
[DJG - Nowadays we've changed this a bit. 2D to show the BWDH
is all
very well, but in several years of play it never once came up. So
I got
the idea of using 2D to show a hand with the black suits worth a
reverse
(i.e., about 16-18 points); this would allow 1S to be a limit
bid, which
would be nice. Chris Monsour objected to this -- I still think
he's
wrong, but we went along with him. So now 1C-1H;2D shows *either*
the
club-spade reverse, *or* an unbalanced hand with clubs, 4 hearts,
and
short diamonds. Responder relays with 2H, after which 2S is clubs
and
spades, and higher bids show a heart raise and some other
feature: 2NT
for 4-4-1-4 distribution; 3C to emphasize the club suit; 3D to
show a
concentration of values in spades; 3H to emphasize good heart
support.
1C-1H;2S then no longer includes hands with short diamonds --
after the
2NT relay, 3C is the BWDH; 3D and 3H show short spades. I don't
think
we've come to a definite conclusion on what 3D and 3H are, but I
think
3D should be a concentration of values in diamonds, and 3H should
deny one.
This has some advantage of consistency with 1D auctions --
1m-1H;2S-2NT;3m
always shows the BWDH.]
3H: Balanced 4-card raise with 17-18 support points.
Unbalanced raises go
through 2S.
[DJG - On this particular auction, since opener shows a balanced
hand,
3NT is to play rather than being "Serious 3NT". 3S
becomes an artificial
slam try.]
3S: RKC in spades.
1C 1S ?
2D: 5 or more clubs, 4 hearts, and about 11-14 points,
nonforcing but
seldom passed. This hand is a problem in this and similar
systems. The
"weak reverse" is the lower bid because responder with
a weak hand, four
spades, and long diamonds can pass.
[DJG - But in practice will rarely do so, for fear that opener
(who
has shown 9 cards in the round suits) is short. After 1C-1S;2D,
all non-jump rebids (including 2NT) by responder are to play, and
3D is 4th suit forcing!]
2H: This is the "strong reverse," showing about
15-18 points in this
system.
3H: RKC in hearts.
3S: A four-card raise with 17-18 support points, balanced or unbalanced.
[DJG - Nowadays we play that 3S promises a balanced hand,
while 3H shows
a short red suit. Again, analogous to auctions after a 1D
opening, and
far more useful than 3H as heart RKC.]
1.2.0 After The 1S Rebid
1C 1H 1S ?
Opener shows 11-18 points, at least four clubs, exactly four
spades, and
less than four hearts. Opener may be balanced and may have three
hearts.
Pass: Bad hand, usually 3 but sometimes 4 spades.
1NT: 6-9 points, in principle. May be unbalanced, especially
with long
diamonds. Shows 4 or 5 hearts, usually less than 4 clubs, and
definitely
less than 4 spades. Opener may raise to 2NT with 17-18 points. 2D
shows a
fragment in an unbalanced hand and suggests a contract if
responder has
diamond length. 2C is natural, as is 3C. 2H is natural and shows
3-card
support, usually with a singleton diamond.
2C: Natural, 6-9 points. Opener's 2D is a directionless force;
2NT is
natural, showing about 17-18 points; and 2H is constructive with
3-card
support. (With a non-constructive hand and 3 hearts, generally
pass.) 3C is
natural and invitational, usually to 3NT.
2D: Artificial one-round force (usually called "fourth
suit forcing" and
abbreviated 4SF, but better called "fourth suit
artificial," a battle
I've given up fighting). If responder next bids a previously-bid
but
unsupported suit, it is game-forcing and shows four-card support
or a
self-sufficient suit (in the case of 3H). If responder instead
bids 2NT, it
is invitational. If opener bids 2H, responder's 3H is
invitational. (Any
spade or club bid, or 3H over anything but 2H, is forcing.)
Responder's
3D bid is GF with at least 5 diamonds but maybe only 4 hearts.
(Remember,
respond 1M even with a longer minor.) This is the original Acol
version of
4SF. There are others.
2H: Good suit, but not invitational. Opener may bid again with
16 or so
points and 3-card support.
2S: Usually 4-card support but 3-card support in a pinch. Must
have some
hope for game opposite the right 17-point hand, else pass.
Chance-giving,
not invitational.
2NT: 10-11 points balanced.
3C: Invitational values, at least four clubs. Opener's bids
are forcing to
4C; an immediate 4C is RKC in clubs.
3D: At least 6 diamonds, probably only 4 hearts. About 8-11
points or
exciting distribution, so invitational in principle. With a
weaker hand
rebid 1NT. Not forcing.
3H: Self-sufficient suit, invitational values. Not forcing.
Stronger hands
go through 4SF.
3S: 4-card support, invitational values. Not forcing. Again,
stronger hands
use 4SF.
3NT: About 12-15 points, balanced or nearly balanced. Opener
should bid
over this only with an absolute maximum.
1.2.1 After The 1NT Rebid
1C 1M 1NT ?
Opener has a balanced hand with less than four diamonds, less
than four of
responder's major suit, less than four spades unless specifically
4-3-3-3,
and 15-16 points. Responder will usually be able to pass, sign
off, or bid
game, but may occasionally want opener's help in deciding on a
contract.
2C: Invitational puppet. Opener must rebid 2D. Responder's
rebids are
natural.
2D: Game-forcing Stayman. Opener shows four cards in the other
major
or 3-card support for partner's suit, 3C with five, or 2NT
otherwise.
(With five diamonds in this range the opening bid would have been
1D.) Responder's rebids are game-forcing and natural and may be
slam
invitational by inference.
2S: After first bidding 1H, this shows an invitational hand
with 4 spades
and 6 hearts. Opener is expected to select the final contract.
2NT: Baron, slam invitational. Responder doesn't much need a
natural
invitational 2NT, since opener is so limited, but in any case 2C
followed
by 2NT is available. Over the Baron 2NT opener is expected to bid
any suit
with extra length, with 3D showing 3, and skipping over 3D
showing two.
Opener has shown at least 3 clubs by not raising responder's
major, so 3C
shows 4.
Other: To play, even if a jump bid.
1.2.2 After The 2C Rebid
Opener shows 19 or more points, not necessarily all in high
cards, with any
distribution. This rebid establishes a game force; in general
other rebids
are not even 1-round forces.
1C 1M 2C ?
2D: Artificial, 10-12 points. One would expect a Herbert
negative here, but
it seems best to divide responder's hands into three ranges.
Bidding is now
natural. Opener's 2M shows at least 3-card support; with 5
responder now
always bids 3M and Serious 3NT applies. If responder bids
something else,
denying 5, opener bids 3M with four-card support and again
Serious 3NT is
on. (In principle, 3NT by either partner when the bidding is at
the 3-level
and an 8-card major-suit fit has been established, shows serious
interest
in slam and asks partner to cuebid any control if slam is still
possible.
Skipping suits at the 3-level Husually spades, with hearts
agreedS denies
a control, since 3-level cuebids take priority over Serious 3NT.
Bypassing
3NT in these circumstances to cuebid at the 4-level shows a hand
where
slam is still possible but partner must have a very good hand.)
Here, of
course, opener realizes that slam requires only a little extra or
a fit or
a running suit.
Other: Natural, 6-9 or 13+ points. Bidding 2H after first
responding 1S
shows at least 5 spades, but bidding 2S after first bidding
hearts only
shows 4+ hearts and 4 spades, unless by chance responder is 5-6
in spades
and hearts. 2NT doesn't guarantee stoppers. 3m shows at least
Qxxx, so 2NT
may be a catchall. Responder should rebid a 5-card major suit
rather than
showing a 4-card minor, and failing to rebid the major tends to
deny 5
cards. Responder shows 13+ by bidding over game without being
invited to do
so, or by bidding a Serious 3NT if that applies. Either would be
a breach
of captaincy with 6-9.
[DJG - Note well that "3m shows at least Qxxx" -- it
can be extremely
handy for responder to promise that honor card! Of course, I'm
biased,
since that was my idea.]
This is a very important area of bidding. Study and practice
will be
rewarded.
[DJG - 1C-1M;2C is one of the more common sequences.]
1.2.3 The Weak Reverse
1C 1S 2D ?
Opener has about 11 to a bad 15 points, 5 or more clubs, and 4
hearts (not
a typo). This is a problem hand for systems of this sort, and in
fact
is the reason Polish Club uses a Precision-style 2C opening. Over
this
minimum-showing bid, only 3D is forcing.
Pass: Overall misfit, at least 5 and usually 6 diamonds,
little or no
chance of game.
2H: To play. 3 or 4 hearts, little or no chance of game.
2S: Signoff in principle, but opener with a maximum and fit can bid on.
2NT: Invitational in notrump, diamond stopper.
3C: Club fit, about 6-11 points. Opener may bid. Clumsy, but rare.
3D: Fourth-suit forcing. Here it's a game force. Opener will
usually rebid
3H, but may bid 3S or 3NT or 4C with a suitable hand. (It only
sounds like
a raise.)
3H: Almost always 4-card support, invitational values. Not forcing.
3S: 6- or very good 5-card suit, strongly invitational but not forcing.
3NT: To play.
4C: Invitational, very good clubs.
4D: Splinter in support of hearts.
4H: To play. 3D followed by 4H would be stronger.
4S: To play.
1.2.4 The Real Reverse
1C 1S 2H ?
Opener has a good 15 to any 18 points, at least 5 clubs, and
four hearts.
While this reverse is not forcing, responder can't pass without
support so
structured methods are justified. Throughout the system, the
cheaper of 4th
suit and 2NT is an artificial negative; here 2NT. 2S is forcing
but not
necessarily strong; other bids deny 5 spades in principle.
Pass: 3 or 4 hearts, little or no chance of game.
2S: Unassuming; that is, forcing but not necessarily strong.
Shows 5 spades
but says little else about the hand. Opener may raise to 4 with
3-card
support and a maximum. Natural bidding follows. If responder next
bids 3S,
it is constructive but not forcing.
2NT: Artificial negative. Shows exactly four spades. Little or
no chance of
game. Opener will almost always rebid 3C, which responder will
often pass.
In any case, opener must pass responder's rebid.
3C: Game forcing, natural.
3D: Notrump try without a diamond stopper, or very strong hand
that will be
clarified on the next round. Game forcing.
3H: Game-forcing, natural.
3S: Good six-card suit, game-forcing values.
3NT: To play. May be shaded, since 2NT is not available as an invitation.
1.2.5 The Death Hand Becomes A Friend
1C 1H 2D ?
Opener shows at least 6 clubs, the values for 3C, but with
3-card heart
support. This hand type is called the "Bridge World Death
Hand" because
it kept showing up in the Bridge World magazine's "Master
Solvers' Club"
and because there is really no good way to bid it in standard
methods.
Responder's new suits are forcing and may be short.
2H: To play.
2S: Game forcing; often a stopper.
2NT: Invitational. Stoppers. Not a good hand, almost always only 4 hearts.
3C: To play.
3D: Game forcing; usually a stopper but may be natural. May be
the first
move on a strong hand with 5 or more hearts.
3H: Strongly invitational with good hearts.
3S: Splinter, five or more hearts, game forcing.
3NT: To play.
[DJG - This whole section is now obsolete, as mentioned above.]
1.2.6 The Single Raise
1C 1M 2M ?
Opener has less than 17 support points (about 13-16) and
either 3-card or
4-card support. Opener can be balanced or unbalanced. If
unbalanced with
3-card support opener will be toward a minimum. Opener may have
15 HCP
balanced with a small doubleton and either 3- or 4-card support
(or of
course 4-card support without a small doubleton). With 14 or so
HCP and a
singleton and only 3-card support opener will strain to find a
different
rebid. 3-card raises make life more difficult but are good
bridge.
2NT: Forcing, but invitational with only four cards in M. Now
opener rebids
3C with a minimum and 3-card support (and incidentally at least 5
clubs),
3M with a minimum and 4-card support, usually 4M with a maximum
and 4- card
support, and something else (typically a stopper) with a maximum
and 3-card
support. 3NT will usually be a balanced 15 HCP with a small
doubleton,
counting on partner for a stopper. New suits may be bid with
either 3- or
4-card support. An unbalanced maximum will be very unusual.
3C: Constructive game try with only four in the major but at
least 3-card
club support. Opener will pass with a minimum and 3-card support,
bid
3M with a minimum and 4-card support, bid 4M with a maximum and
4- card
support, and as usual do something else with a maximum and 3-card
support;
3NT if balanced. Unbalanced maximum 3-card support is unlikely.
Other: If 3M or below, a natural forcing game try with at
least 5 cards
in M. If above 3M, a slam try; usually a splinter; except 3NT is
to play
opposite 3- card support. Opener should correct to 4M with 4.
With no
singleton and slam-invitational values, try 2NT to get more
information.
1.2.7 The Marvelous Toy
1C 1H 2S ?
Opener has 4-card support, an unbalanced hand, and 17-18 or so
support
points. This is possible because the 1S rebid shows 11-18 points
with
spades and the 2C rebid shows any hand with 19 or more points. 2S
isn't
needed to show spades.
2NT: Relay for more information. Now 3C shows a singleton
spade (black
suit), 3D shows 4-4-1-4, and 3H shows 5 or more clubs with a
singleton
diamond (red suit). Responder can decide whether or not to bid
game or bid
or try for slam, knowing opener's distribution and strength.
[DJG - Somewhat different now, as detailed above. 3C shows the
BWDH,
3D some diamond strength with spade shortness, 3H little diamond
strength
(hence probably good clubs).]
3H: To play. Doesn't care about opener's shortness, there's no game.
4H: To play. Doesn't care about opener's shortness, there's
game but no
slam.
Other: Unusual, but slam try. Responder will usually ask for
more
information first.
1.2.8 The 2NT Rebid
1C 1M 2NT ?
Opener shows 17-18 HCP balanced. If bid over 1H, opener will
have 4 spades
only with exactly 4-3-3-3 distribution. Opener will not have
4-card support
but will often have 3-card support; and of course less than four
diamonds.
A weak doubleton is unlikely but possible, since the raise to 3M
requires
4-card support. Checkback or New Minor Forcing buys very little
in this
auction and loses a useful natural bid. Therefore:
3suit: 3 of any suit is natural and forcing.
3NT: To play.
4C: Gerber. Since 3C is natural and forcing, 4C is not needed
as a natural
bid.
4M: To play.
4NT: Natural, invites 6NT.
1.2.9 Deja Vu
1C 1M 3C ?
As before, opener has a hand too strong to be opened 2C but
not strong
enough for a 2C rebid, at least 6 clubs, and no four-card or
longer major.
If responder bid 1H, opener denies as many as 3 hearts (else 2D).
Responder
bids exactly as in section 1.1.7: any bid over 3C other than a
game bid or
raise is forcing, since 3C must be assumed playable. Because
responder is
unlimited, bidding a new suit and then 4C is forcing as well. As
usual,
3-level bids may be stoppers.
1.2.10 The Card-Asking Rebids
1C 1M ?
Opener's rebids of 3D, 3OM, and 4C are RKC in the named suit.
3NT is the
specific Ace ask, as over the 1D response. Again, if you use
these things
more than once in a blue moon you're probably abusing them, but
under a
blue moon they may give you a very good result. (There are good
arguments
for redefining these bids as something else. To say that they are
rare is a
considerable understatement.)
1.2.11 The Game Raise
1C 1M 4M
Opener has 18 or occasionally 19 HCP with a doubleton, or 19
point 4333.
Stronger hands go through the 2C rebid. Responder's rebids are as
in
standard; new suits are cuebids and 4NT is RKC.
1.3 After the Wide-Ranging 1NT Response
1C 1NT ?
Responder has 10-15 HCP, no 4-card major, and no 5-card minor
unless in
the 10-12 range. Even then, the minor should be weak. With 13 or
more and
four good clubs responder should prefer 2C. 1NT here is forcing
but not
to game. (For those concerned with the ACBL General Convention
Chart, the
prohibition against 1NT showing invitational or better values
applies
only after a major-suit opening. Further, this 1NT is natural and
not
conventional, so arguably not subject to regulation.)
Why the wide range? When we used 10-12, we discovered we
always bid over it
anyway, so why not make it explicitly forcing? And if it's
forcing, we can
afford a wider range.
2C: Minimum with clubs. Not forcing. For once the Herbert
negative is
natural! Responder's new suits are forcing but not necessarily to
game.
2D: Artificial game force but not necessarily very strong.
Responder's
rebids show honor concentrations. Usually this leads to a choice
of games
between 3NT and 5m, but occasionally opener will have a very
strong 4441
and other contracts will be in the picture.
2M: 19+ points, at least five cards in the suit bid. Obviously
game forcing
and slam invitational. Responder bids naturally, raising with
Hxx.
Note that after 1C-2m, the 2M rebids are stoppers.
As a general rule, though, when one partner has bid
notrump naturally, we don't show stoppers.
2NT: Slam try with length in both minors. Responder will
usually bid 3m
with a preference, 3M with 4-4 and a control in the suit bid.
3C: The usual strong club 1-suiter. May be the first move with
a 19+ point
hand with primary clubs. Responder's 3-level bids are assumed
initially to
be solid stoppers for notrump. Natural bidding follows.
3D: 19+ points, 5+ diamonds. Game forcing, slam invitational.
Natural
bidding follows.
3M: Shortness. Invites 3NT if responder has a solid stopper,
else (usually)
5C.
3NT: About 15-17 balanced, although may be slightly weaker with 5C422.
4C: Gerber, in a strange way. Takes the place of the RKC and
specific aces
bids after other responses.
4NT: Natural, invites slam.
1.4 The "Inverted" Raise
1C 2C ?
Responder has 10 or more points, at least four good clubs, and
no 4-card
major. Unlimited. Either partner may show a minimum or identify
stoppers.
2D: Herbert negative, 11-14 points. Responder must bid 3C with
a minimum,
which will be passed. Any other bid by responder is game-forcing;
a 2NT
rebid is unlimited and stronger than 3NT.
2H: A good 14 or more points, as above. Heart stopper, may or
may not have
a spade stopper. Bidding proceeds naturally.
2S: As above; spade stopper but no heart stopper.
2NT: 15 or more points, stoppers. Forcing at least to 3NT.
3C: Game forcing, no stopper in either major or big hand with clubs.
3D, 3M: 19+ points, 5+ cards in the bid suit.
1.5 The Diamond Positive
1C 2D ?
Responder has at least 10 points and at least 5 diamonds, with
no 4-card
major. If 10-12 points responder is either unbalanced or has a
lot of
strength in diamonds.
2H: Herbert negative. 11-14 points.
Other bidding largely as above, except that 3D shows real support.
1.6 The Major Semi-Positives
1C 2M ?
Responder has about 5-8 HCP and a good 6-card suit. If
responder is a
passed hand, a bad 6-card suit, since a good one would have been
opened
a weak 2-bid. Use whatever methods you usually use over a weak
2-bid.
I recommend new suits forcing with 2NT asking for a high-card
feature.
(There's actually a lot to be said for Ogust here.)
1.7 The 2NT Response
1C 2NT ?
Responder shows 16 or more points balanced, with no 4-card
major. If four
clubs, they aren't particularly good, else 2C. Bidding proceeds
pretty much
as over 1NT, a level higher, except of course that 3C is forcing.
1.8 The Weak Double Raise
1C 3C ?
Responder has less than about 6 points and long clubs. Tend to
use the 1D
negative with a useful hand. Opener will almost always pass. Any
bid at the
3-level should be assumed initially to be a stopper for notrump,
but may
turn out to be natural by the logic of the auction. In any case,
opener's
new suits are forcing.
2 Dealing With Interference
It's at least as important to know how to bid in contested
auctions as it
is in uncontested ones. Opponents tend to bid a lot, and the 1C
opening is
sufficiently ambiguous that interference causes some embarassing
problems.
Agreements are essential.
2.0 Immediate Interference
1C (interference) ?
Responder must be prepared to deal with interference. At the
1-level,
because opener's hand is poorly defined, we strain to define
responder's as
quickly as possible. At the 2-level we have been hurt, at least a
little,
and try to fight back by doubling the opponents when it's
appropriate. This
flies in the face of much modern bidding theory but our results
have been
excellent. It simply can't be winning bridge to let the opponents
take away
more than an entire level of bidding and never be made to pay for
it. At
the 3-level we revert to negative doubles and hope to hold our
own in the
usual ways.
In general, I try to retain as many meanings as possible
unchanged from the
main system, so that the many specialized methods need not be
abandoned
unnecessarily. When the usual methods must be abandoned, 2NT may
be used
as an artificial strong bid by either partner. Opener's 1NT rebid
after
either a negative response or a pass shows about 17-20 points
balanced,
with appropriate stoppers, and a cuebid shows support or a good
hand with
no stopper, depending on context.
1C (Dbl) ?
Pass: 0-5 points, any distribution. An immediate double
negative. Opener
should proceed with caution.
Rdbl: 10 points or more, 4 or more clubs, no 4-card major. The
usual club
positive, but a level lower than usual.
1D: 6-9 points, at least 5 diamonds, no 4-card major. Diamond
semi-positive. Opener's rebids are natural; even a pass is
possible.
2C: 6-9 points, at least four clubs, no 4-card major. Club
semi-positive.
This and the redouble have been inverted from what one would tend
to expect
because the 2C call has some preemptive value.
Other: As they would have been without the double. We wish the
opponents
would double more often.
1C (1D) ? (We assume the interference is natural. If not,
double with
length in the suit.)
Pass: 0-5 points, any distribution, or long diamonds. Again, a
double
negative, but this one includes the diamond positive.
Dbl: Diamond semi-positive. That is, more or less penalty.
With majors, .
bid one This fills a systemic gap. A negative double doesn't .
2C: 6-9 points, clubs, no 4-card major.
2D: Club positive. The cuebid will generally be a club positive.
Other: As it would be without the overcall.
1C (1H) ?
Pass: Too weak for any other call (usually 0-5), or heart
length. Opener
bids as in the "delayed interference" auctions below.
That is, 1C (1H) Pass
(Pass) is a situation very similar to 1C (Pass) 1D (1H).
Dbl: Some values but no other good call, therefore less than 4
spades;
usually at least four diamonds and less than positive values.
Responder
must strain to define the hand. A negative double showing 4
spades is a
luxury we can't afford. The diamond semi-positive seems a better
use. Now
opener's 2C is strong and a cuebid by either partner usually
denies a
stopper (else NT).
1S: At least 6 points, at least four spades, as without the overcall.
1NT: About 8-10 points balanced with a stopper, less than 4
spades. Notrump
bids become limit in competition.
2C: Club semi-positive. In competition we can't afford to temporize.
2H: As usual, the cuebid shows the club positive. This is
standard bidding,
the "Unassuming Cuebid" that inspired the name
"Unassuming Club".
2NT: 11-12 points balanced, less than 4 spades, good stopper.
Other: As without the interference.
1C (1S) ?
Pass: Negative or spade length, but not a club semi-positive
or 8-9
balanced.
Dbl: Ordinary heart positive. Bid as if 1H response, but Q asks stopper.
1NT: Balanced 8-10 points, spade stopper, less than 4 hearts.
2C: Club semi-positive.
2H: 10+ points, at least five hearts. Natural and forcing.
With
game-forcing values and more than 4 hearts it's important to bid
the suit.
2S: Club positive.
Other: As without the interference.
1C (1NT) ?
If this is a "notrump overcall," that is, intended
to show a balanced hand
of somewhere in the range of 14-19 points, use normal methods.
Responder
should double with nearly any hand of 9 or more points, and a lot
of
8-point hands. 2NT is artificial and strong, and very
distributional
(usually a strong 2-suiter). Other bids are limited by the
failure to
double. The double is forcing to 3C.
If it's something like a weak takeout double (part of
"Overcall
Structure"), double should require a little more: a good
10-11 points,
usually balanced. Again, you may not pass out the opponents
undoubled in a
contract below 3C. This is more like a redouble than the
penalty-oriented
double of a natural 1NT overcall. The extra values required are
because
this double often helps the opponents wriggle out.
1C (2suit) ?
A bit of philosophy: You are being hurt by these overcalls. To
break even,
you have to double them from time to time. What follows is an
attempt to
balance penalty-hunting and constructive bidding.
Double: Penalty double opposite a 15-18-point 1NT opening.
With 7-9 HCP,
consider doubling with a balanced or semibalanced hand with 3 to
an honor.
Nearly always double with 7-9 and 4 cards. Usually double with 6
points
and 4 cards. Be careful with 10 points or more, but consider
doubling.
Opener should pass the double with any strong notrump or other
suitable
hand. Cue with game values opposite a minimum double. Bid a new
suit at
the 2-level with 4. 3C may conceal a 4-card suit that can't be
bid at
the 2-level. Opener's 2NT is artificial, showing a strong hand,
as is
responder's over a 2-level pull. Opener's 3-level bids are
invitational
opposite a typical double, i.e., maximum non-strong 1C openings,
except
that 3C shows a minimum.
2NT: Hand worth a GF opposite a strong notrump. Opener rebids
3C with a
minimum, which responder may pass. (Opener always has real clubs
when
minimum.) 3D may be bid either with diamonds or a directionless
hand;
higher bids show 19+ points, except 3NT which is natural.
2suit: Not forcing, but some reason to bid. Natural.
3suit: Constructive, invitational opposite a strong notrump.
1C (3any) ?
Double: Negative. Shows values to be at the 3-level; will
often be passed.
Exception: a double of 3C is penalty. Opener will almost always
have long
clubs or good defense (i.e., a strong notrump).
Other: Non-game bids are forcing, essentially to game.
Responder will pass with quite a few hands; opener is not
forced to reopen
with shortness, but often will. If the reopening bid is a double
it is for
takeout, but responder will often pass.
2.1 Delayed Interference
It matters a good deal what responder bids. If the response
was a positive,
you are on pretty firm ground. Use whatever methods you are used
to,
although I believe when using a weak notrump the double of a
fourth-hand
overcall should show a strong notrump with less than 3 cards in
partner's
suit, and you should raise very freely on 3-card support. The key
situation
is when responder has bid 1D, the negative.
1C 1D (Dbl) ?
Redouble: Strong balanced hand without a diamond stopper,
assuming the
double shows diamonds.
Other: Same as in uncontested auctions, except that all
notrump bids show a
diamond stopper.
1C 1D (1H) ?
Pass: Usually long hearts, either 4-4-1-4 or 4 hearts with 5 clubs.
Double: Takeout. Usually 4-1-3-5 or 4-2-3-4, but may be nearly
any hand of
19 or more points, or occasionally 3-1-3-6.
Other: Same as without intereference, except cuebid is strong
balanced hand
without a stopper and notrump bids show a heart stopper. 2C is
strong.
1C 1D (1S) ?
Pass: Long spades; or minimum hand with nothing better to bid;
may be up to
16 points balanced.
Double: Takeout, as above, but includes many strong hands.
1NT: 17-20 points balanced, stopper or at least lead value.
Strong notrump
methods are on.
Other: Same as without interference, except cuebid is a strong
hand,
usually balanced without a stopper. Again, 2C is strong.
Over higher-level interference, opener's direct bids are
usually the strong
hands, except that 3C will often be natural. 2NT will usually
show a strong
hand, with the inference that other bids show hands not so
strong. Double
is not well defined, since it will often be the only available
call. The
general idea is to keep as much as possible of the original
system. Since
the 1H rebid will often be unavailable, the 2C rebid must handle
a variety
of strong hands.
3 The 1NT Opening
1NT ?
Opener has a good 11 to any 14 HCP. Opener will hardly ever
have a
5-card major; if one is held, it will be no better than J9xxx and
the
doubleton will be strong. If the hand is 5422, there will be
honors in
both doubletons. In a 5m332 or 4432 hand, a small doubleton is
fine.
Actually any schedule of responses you're used to using over
either a weak
or a strong notrump is fine. There is a lot to be said for using
Jacoby
transfers. There are advantages to two-way Stayman, as well, and
it's
simpler, but it's not mandatory.
2C: Stayman. Usually invitational values. Opener rebids 2D
with no 4-card
major, the major held with one, and 2H with both. Opener may bid
2C with
game-forcing values and weak diamonds, trying to avoid a
lead-directing
double of diamonds, but must be able to set the final contract
after
hearing opener's rebid. Over opener's rebid, responder's bids are
natural
and invitational.
2D: Game-forcing, artificial. Opener bids a 4-card major
(hearts with
both), jumping with a maximum and concentrated values; or a
5-card minor;
or 2NT with none of the above. Responder's rebids are natural and
game-
forcing. Responder's 2NT asks for suits, Baron-style. With four
spades,
responder bids 2NT over hearts. By a passed hand, 2D is to play.
2M: To play. Opener may bid again with 4-card support. If
opener bids a new
suit it shows a doubleton.
2NT: Natural raise, usually denying a 4-card major.
3m: To play. Opener will hardly ever bid again.
3H: Invitational, 5-5 in the majors.
3S: Game forcing, 5-5 in the majors. Responder may bid again
over the
preference.
3NT: To play, of course.
4C: Gerber. First step shows no Aces, second shows one, and so
forth. 5C is
the King ask; 4NT is to play.
4D: Transfer to 4H. If responder then bids 4NT, it's RKC. This
is the
primary argument for using Texas over a weak notrump.
4H: Transfer to spades, as above.
4S: Slam try with at least four cards in each minor.
4NT: Natural invitation to 6NT. If opener bids a suit, it is a
suggestion
of a suit slam.
3.0 Dealing With Interference
The worst kind of interference is the double. If your
opponents are any
good, this is probably for penalty and you're usually in trouble.
There
are many runout systems on the market, including one I prefer,
but they
don't seem to make a difference very often. Simply playing
"systems off"
(all bids natural and nonforcing), redouble with near-game
values, and
bidding a short suit and redoubling to give opener a choice, will
handle
most situations.
Following early versions of the Kaplan-Sheinwold system, after
1NT (Pass)
I recommend trying very hard to find a bid with less than about 6
points,
and doubling opponents' overcalls for penalty. In fact, doubles
by either
partner should be penalty with the sole exception of 1NT (2any) P
(P); dbl.
This shows a small doubleton in the opponents' suit and a maximum
weak NT.
The general rule about free bids is, 2-level bids are not
forcing; 3-level
bids are. That is especially true if you use 2NT as a puppet, the
so-called
Lebensohl convention. It's a good rule anyway, though.
As before, though, it's possible to use the free 2NT as a
strong puppet,
making 3-level bids invitational in principle. In fact, I believe
this has
technical advantages. Here, it may include a club signoff.
4 The 2C Opening
2C ?
Opener shows 10-15 HCP, a 6-card suit, and no 4-card major. A
4-card
diamond suit is okay. The low end of this bid looks like a
high-end weak
2-bid. The high end is just short of a jump rebid; 15 HCP will
actually
be rather rare. Responder may transfer into a major or make an
immediate
game-forcing jump, or explore with the 2S relay.
2D: Transfer to hearts. This may be a very weak hand with long
hearts or
any of a variety of constructive hands, but if game-forcing
generally less
than 6 cards. With 0-2 cards in hearts, opener bids 2H. With 3
opener bids
something else, usually shortness, otherwise natural. If
responder then
bids 3D, it is a command to bid 3H, which responder will
presumably pass. A
bid of 3H is invitational. Natural bidding follows.
2H: Transfer to spades, as above.
2S: Artificial inquiry. See below.
2NT: Natural, invitational.
3C: Not constructive. For opener to bid over this requires a 7-card suit.
3other: Forcing, usually a 6-card suit, although 3D will often be only 5.
3NT: To play.
4C: To play.
4D: RKC for clubs.
Other: To play.
Dealing with interference: There is little need for a negative
double.
Doubles are penalty and free bids are forcing for one round.
After
a takeout double, responder should redouble with a hand suitable
to
penalizing the opponents, otherwise ignore the double.
4.0 The Inquiry
2C 2S ?
This is ostensibly a try for 3NT but may also be bid with a
strong hand
with club support, looking for a club slam. The responses are
designed for
the notrump exploration, though.
2NT: Minimum, two stoppers. Now responder's 3C is a signoff;
3D asks for
the unstopped suit; and higher bids are forcing and presumed
natural.
3C: Minimum, 1 stopper. Now pass is the signoff (!) and 3D
asks for the
stopped suit. (3NT shows diamonds stopped.)
3D: Maximum, diamond stopper, one or both majors unstopped.
Responder will
usually bid a stopped major if one is held, or 3NT with both.
3H: Maximum, no diamond stopper, maybe a spade stopper. With
both spades
and diamonds stopped responder will usually bid 3NT. 3S shows a
diamond
stopper and denies a spade stopper. A moment's reflection will
confirm that
this the only meaning that makes sense.
3S: Maximum, spade stopper, no red-suit stopper.
3NT: Maximum, all side suits stopped, therefore rather weak clubs.
Responder's 4-level non-club bids in any of these auctions are
tries for a
club slam.
Students of bidding theory will note that the part of the 2S
system from 3D
up cannot be done with ordinary relays; there are 7 hands and
only 5 can
be shown with strict relay auctions. The scheme above handles it
nicely.
Relays aren't optimal.
5 The 1D Opening
The announced range for 1D is 11-18 points. Especially if you
use a weak
2D, as I prefer to, the 11-point hand that is opened 1D will look
more
like 13. Opener will have at least four diamonds. Responder will
bid with
almost all hands with 6 HCP and some with 5. Opener cannot force
to game,
or usually even the 3-level, without a fit. Opener's natural
jump-shift
rebids and reverses are not even 1-round forces.
For the most part, bidding over 1D will be the same as in
standard
bidding. However, the fact that opener has at most 18 HCP can be
used to
advantage, and something must be done about the problem of
undefined length
in minor two-suiters. When you open one of a major, you will
often play in
that suit. When you open a minor suit, especially playing 5-card
majors,
you will often play in a major suit or notrump. Only a few
auctions will be
given here; the rest are as in standard methods.
1D 1M
At least two styles are possible. One is the standard approach
where 1M
may conceal a longer club suit only with less than the values
needed for
a 2C response. The other is the approach used after the 1C
opening, where
bidding a minor denies a 4-card major (MAFIA, for Majors Always
First In
Answering). I prefer the former, but it would more consistent to
use the
latter. It's your call. Discuss it with your partner.
1D 2D
I much prefer the approach to inverted minor raises that goes
back to early
Kaplan-Sheinwold. 2D denies a 4-card major, shows at least 4
diamonds, and
shows at least 9 points not necessarily all in high cards. Opener
with a
minimum bids 3D, even if 4441. 2NT shows a balanced hand with
stoppers. New
suits show game-forcing values and in principle a stopper in the
suit bid.
3M is a game-forcing splinter.
1D 2C
I prefer to play this as a relatively standard 2/1, not game
forcing.
Responder may have a balanced hand, planning to rebid 2NT, or a
club
1-suiter just less than game-forcing values.
In this awkward auction I prefer Kokish's rebids, outlined in
Lawrence's
2/1 Workbook. Opener rebids 2D with 5 or more diamonds (forcing,
range
not specified), 2H with 4-4-1-4 (again, ambiguous strength), 2S
with
balanced game-forcing values and club support, 2NT (game forcing)
with
a strong notrump, 3C with a minimum and club support, 3D
standard, and
3M a splinter. Only opener's 3C rebid is not forcing. After 2D or
2H,
responder's new suits are forcing but 2NT, 3C, and 3D are not.
This
requires responder to bid a second suit in order to force, but
responder's
second suits should always be viewed with a certain amount of
suspicion.
1D 1H 2S
"Marvelous toy" revisited. The 1S rebid is adequate
for all hands with
diamonds and spades in the 11-18-point range. Stronger hands open
1C. That
frees 2S for artificial uses. We use it for unbalanced 4-card
raises to 3S
and for the Bridge World Death Hand. (We can handle the
"Death Hand" very
nicely when the response is hearts. We can't when it's spades.)
As in the
club part of the system, responder will usually relay with 2NT
and now
opener's rebids are:
3C: Club fragment (therefore spade shortness), 4-card support.
3D: Diamond 1-suiter worth an immediate 3D rebid, but with 3 hearts (BWDH).
3H: The remaining hand: spade fragment, club shortness, 4-card support.
1D 1S 3H
In standard bidding this is a heart splinter in support of
spades. I prefer
to use it as any unbalanced raise to 3S, so that the regular
raise shows a
balanced hand. Now 3NT is Serious and 4C asks for shortness;
opener's 4D
shows club shortness and 4H shows heart shortness.
1D 1any 2C
Minimum 5-5, or 5-4 either way, or even 4-4 in certain cases.
Opener
will seldom have more than about 15 points. Responder need not
strain
to bid with a weak hand. The preference is nonforcing, as is a
rebid of
responder's suit.
1D 1M 3C
As with all of opener's jump-shift rebids, this is not
forcing. It shows at
least 16 points (not necessarily all in high cards) and at least
5 diamonds
and 4 clubs. Diamonds will always be at least as long as clubs;
responder
should give a preference with equal length. The preference and
rebid of
responder's suit are nonforcing; 3OM is the generic force.
1D 1M 1NT
15-17 HCP. Over 1H, denies a 4-card spade suit; in any case
denies 4-card
support. With 3-card support and a small doubleton or two
unstopped suits,
consider 2M. Continue as after a 1C opening: 2C is an
invitational puppet
and 2D is game-forcing checkback. 18+ balanced is opened 1C. That
allows
...
1D 1M 2NT
This shows the minor-suit reverse. Opener has longer clubs
than diamonds
and a maximum. 3C, 3D, and 3M now are nonforcing. (This is the
downside of
nonforcing jump-shifts. You squander bidding space and auctions
may still
be awkward.) 3OM asks for a stopper or 3-card support.
1D 1S 2H
This can be passed, but only with partial support (xxx or
better). As in
the similar auction after 1C, responder's 2NT is an artificial
negative,
2S shows 5 or more and ambiguous strength, and a bid of either of
opener's
suits at the 3-level is forcing to game.
6 The Major-Suit Openings
There's not much to be said here. These openings are limited
to about
11-18 points, with at least 5 cards in the suit opened, with the
remote
possibility of a longer club suit. Use whatever methods you find
most
comfortable, except that jump-shift rebids and reverses aren't
forcing.
(Responder may have as few as 6 HCP and opener at most 18.
Responder must
be allowed to pass with a misfit.) Be a little freer with
preemptive
raises, especially with some values, when you can judge that
opener can't
have enough for game.
Again, there's a lot to be said for using ROMEX methods here.
They have
been designed with a very similar 1M opening in mind. My
preferences run
more to Lawrence and Bergen, but I'm not convinced one way or the
other.
Faced with creating a standard I will describe my preferences.
The 1NT
response may be passed with 11-13 points and 5332 or 5422
distribution;
otherwise opener may rebid a 6-card suit, a 4-card heart suit, or
a 3-card
minor. Rebidding 2S over 1NT shows 14+ points, usually more.
Responder
strains to make a second bid with 8 points or more. Responder's
2/1
responses are not quite forcing to game; if opener's rebid is at
or below
2M, a rebid of responder's suit is nonforcing. 2NT by either
partner is
forcing to game, although by opener it doesn't necessarily show
any extra
values. Reverses and 3-level rebids (including the raise) show
extra values
and are forcing to game. The single raise is about 6-9 points and
nearly
always 3-card support. Responder's 3M is preemptive, a weak hand
(about 2-6
points) with 4-card support. Responder's 2NT is natural and
forcing, and
over 1S may conceal 4 hearts. Responder's cheapest jump-shift is
a forcing
raise (2S over 1H and 3C over 1S), second-cheapest jump-shift a
mixed
raise (about 7-9 points, 4-card support), and the remaining
jump-shift is
a limit raise. Double jumps are splinters. These methods owe a
lot to Fred
Gitelman, whose articles were available on the web at the time of
this
writing.
7 The 2NT Opening
The 2NT opening is not an essential part of the system. In
fact, only the
1-level bids and 2C are needed in a constructive sense, as in
Standard
American. The rest is up to you. I'm partial to weak 2's, even
2D. Note
that all hands of 19 or more points are opened 1C, so 2NT is not
needed for
a strong balanced hand. We use it for at least 5-5 in the minors,
weak-two
strength, varying somewhat by vulnerability and table position.
2NT ?
3m: To play. Be a little conservative. You may already have won the hand.
3H: Artificial inquiry; see below.
3S: Natural, invitational.
4NT: Forces opener to choose a minor.
Other: To play.
7.0 The Artificial Inquiry
2NT 3H ?
This is a way to try to recover from the damage done when the
2NT opening
preempts our side rather than the opponents. It is possible to
have a
complicated pattern of relays here but I can't remember them,
much less
your partner. The following is as far as I will go along that
line. It has
the advantage of allowing you to play 3NT when it is most likely
to be
right. I can remember this scheme. Perhaps your partner can too.
3S: Minimum 2-1-5-5 or 1-2-5-5. Responder's 3NT rebid is to play.
3NT: Maximum 2-1-5-5 or 1-2-5-5.
4C: Any other minimum. If responder relays with 4D, opener
shows "extra"
cards as below.
Other: Maximum, an "extra" card in the bid suit. NT
bids show extra cards
in both minors. Thus, 4H shows an 0-3-5-5 non-minimum, in
principle, and
4NT shows 1-0-6-6 or 0-1-6-6.
8 In Conclusion
An Unassuming Club will reward the time you and your partner
spend learning
it. The limited opening bids will make your regular methods work
better.
You will be able to use the 1C opening to handle intermediate
hands that
cause trouble for standard bidders. Incautious opponents will
interfere at
the two-level and go for large numbers. Life will be good.
I suggest learning AUC with a partner. What you don't use you
forget. Why
go to the trouble of learning this system if you will just forget
in in a
few weeks?
There are several tools available that will help you practice
this
or any other system. I suggest a computer hand generator for
bidding
practice. There are several on the market. On-line bridge games
offer
an opportunity for casual games at almost any hour of any day.
(Unusual
systems are not welcome at all tables. Be polite if asked to
leave.) I
can often be found on Matt Clegg's OKbridge. Just dealing out
practice
hands and playing rubber bridge, though, will help. Once you have
largely
mastered the system, consider playing it in duplicate bridge
games and
tournaments. It is legal at all levels of tournament bridge, at
least
in North America at the time of this writing. Occasionally there
will
be a discussion of AUC and related systems on the computer
newsgroup
rec.games.bridge. I am willing to answer email. As I write this
my email
address is varvel@ix.netcom.com, but that may change by the time
you read
this; any search engine should be able to find me, though.
[DJG - dvarvel@grandecom.net now]
Good luck!